The Pine Tree, News for Calaveras County and Beyond Weather
Amador Angels Camp Arnold Bear Valley Copperopolis Murphys San Andreas Valley Springs Moke Hill/West Point Tuolumne
Business Directory
Weather & Roads
Real Estate
Weekly & Grocery Ads
Life & Style
Law Enforcement
Wine News
Health & Fitness
Home & Garden
Food & Dining
Religion & Faith
Frogtown USA
Free Classifieds
Letters to the Editor
About Us

Coming Soon...
Thursday, Oct 28
04:00 PM The 2021 Certified Farmers' Market San Andreas is Open Weekly Thursdays 4pm to 6pm!
Friday, Oct 29
All Day Blithe Spirit at Improbable Farce in Three Acts is October 8 - November 7!
Saturday, Oct 30
All Day Blithe Spirit at Improbable Farce in Three Acts is October 8 - November 7!
Sunday, Oct 31
All Day Our Sunday Edition with Local Features, Local Specials & More Every Sunday All Day Long!
All Day Blithe Spirit at Improbable Farce in Three Acts is October 8 - November 7!
09:00 AM Murphys Certified Farmers' Market 2021
Wednesday, Nov 3
06:00 PM Follow the 2021 U.S. Capitol Christmas Tree from California to Washington DC (Including Sonora on No
Friday, Nov 5
All Day Blithe Spirit at Improbable Farce in Three Acts is October 8 - November 7!
Saturday, Nov 6
All Day Drive-Thru Flu Clinic Returns on November 6th
All Day Blithe Spirit at Improbable Farce in Three Acts is October 8 - November 7!
Sunday, Nov 7
All Day Our Sunday Edition with Local Features, Local Specials & More Every Sunday All Day Long!
All Day Blithe Spirit at Improbable Farce in Three Acts is October 8 - November 7!

Search Announcements

Log In


Remember Me

Posted by: thepinetree on 06/30/2021 12:30 PM Updated by: thepinetree on 06/30/2021 12:30 PM
Expires: 01/01/2026 12:00 AM

Earmarks: A Monumentally Bad Idea By Congressman Tom McClintock

Washington, DC...Ever since the Magna Carta, it has been a settled principle of good governance that the power that appropriates public funds should not be the same power that spends them. This principle is at the heart of our Constitution: the separation of powers. Simply speaking, it is mother’s rule writ large. Mother has one slice of pie and two hungry sons. How does she cut the pie so that both brothers are satisfied? One slices, and the other chooses. One brother cannot abuse his powers precisely because of the powers accorded the other.

So it is with our Constitution. One brother makes law but cannot enforce it; the other enforces law but cannot make it. One brother appropriates money but cannot spend it; the other spends money but cannot appropriate it.

Imagine how differently mother’s rule would work if the same brother who sliced the pie also chose his piece.

Yet that is exactly the principle of congressional earmarks: choosing the same slice of pie you have just cut – or more precisely, spending the same money that you have just appropriated. Representatives have already dropped nearly 1,500 earmarks into the so-called infrastructure bill alone – costing $5.7 billion – now that a bipartisan spending frenzy has revived them.

This monumentally bad idea rests on two arguments. The first is that elected Members of Congress, and not unelected bureaucrats, should spend the people’s money. The problem, of course, is that representatives aren’t elected by all the people – only their own distinct constituencies. Representatives are supposed to have a bias toward their own districts. That is why Congress is designed to act collectively to make law and approve the appropriations to support that law. Only the executive answers to the entire nation and can resist the manifest excesses of a body controlled by 535 demanding constituencies and their parochial representatives. That is why appropriating money is a congressional function and spending it is an executive one.

The second argument is that earmarks can “grease” legislation by buying off the votes of individual members whose judgment would otherwise oppose a measure. Add a few local projects for that member, and suddenly a bill he would never vote for on its merits becomes a local imperative overriding his sound judgment. Exactly how is that a good thing? And if earmarks are to be handed out as a reward for voting for legislation, members will prudently keep a list of earmarks handy as the demand to vote for any bill -- whether or not they already plan to support it.

This is not a theoretical discussion. We have learned the hard way what comes from breaching the Constitution’s checks and balances.

The first problem is the corrupting nature of earmarks. When we place the power to appropriate and the power to spend in the same hands, we bypass the most important check against corruption.

A local company produces a product the Pentagon neither needs nor wants. What to do? It simply ingratiates itself with the local congressman and has him tell the Pentagon what it needs and who will provide it. Then it rewards him lavishly at election time and repeats. It should come as no surprise that many of the congressional scandals of the 1990’s and 2000’s arose from earmarks.

Second, earmarks bypass the normal process in which projects compete on their merits. Worthy projects don’t need earmarks if appropriations are spent by the executive branch according to well established competitive, open-bid procedures. Earmarks are only required to protect unworthy projects from merit-driven competition. And even if there is such a thing as a “good” earmark, the price invariably is log-rolling all the bad ones.

Third, earmarks harm the central tenet of federalism: that local projects should be financed by local communities, and federal expenditures reserved for the nation’s general welfare.

When a local government proposes an earmark, what is it saying? The project is so low on its priority list that it doesn’t dare spend its own taxpayers’ funds. But it is perfectly happy to have taxpayers in other communities foot the bill. The result is a grab bag of dubious projects that rob St. Petersburg to pay St. Paul -- for projects that St. Petersburg does not benefit from and that St. Paul doesn’t deem worthy enough to spend its own funds on.

We’ve sung this old song many times before, and it has never ended well.

Comments - Make a comment
The comments are owned by the poster. We are not responsible for its content. We value free speech but remember this is a public forum and we hope that people would use common sense and decency. If you see an offensive comment please email us at
Stand Alone Legislation
Posted on: 2021-06-30 12:58:52   By: Anonymous
IMHO all bills should be singular.
Let Congress work year 'round, and vote on single issues of each bill, not the market basket approach that has passed so much pork even for single individuals slipped into bills.

Gone would be the excuse 'I didn't like the amendments, but did vote for the entire bill".

[Reply ]

No Subject
Posted on: 2021-06-30 14:03:41   By: Anonymous
Brought to you by the same piece of work that says the Yosemite reservation program should be discontinued so that all the crowds can race to our area with the Delta variant.

[Reply ]

    Posted on: 2021-06-30 14:12:39   By: Anonymous
    If Delta takes off like COVID-19 did what difference does it make?? We’ll all be ba to square one and confined to home! Joe Biden was taught by our past president so, now sleepy Joe will handle it well. He’ll get a new vaccine and brag for three more years! Good luck.

    [Reply ]

No Subject
Posted on: 2021-06-30 15:42:35   By: Anonymous
Open Yosemite up, and quit wielding power that only Libtards could think of. I’ll bet the trust funder, dope smoking campground is overflowing, not to mention the bus loads of Asians that take up all the services in the park!

[Reply ]

    Posted on: 2021-06-30 22:04:03   By: Anonymous
    His Dad had one bad monumental idea. Not wearing a rubber.

    [Reply ]

      Posted on: 2021-07-01 06:28:43   By: Anonymous
      Racist comments, by idiots. Thanks DONALD.

      [Reply ]

        Posted on: 2021-07-01 06:33:22   By: Anonymous
        Protect yourself from the coronavirus. Is that to hard to understand. What’s more important, watching tucker or dying in the pandemic.

        [Reply ]

          Posted on: 2021-07-01 06:37:41   By: Anonymous
          Can you say pneumonia. Can you say ventilator . How about respiratory failure. Can you count up to 600,000 ...

          [Reply ]

What's Related
These might interest you as well
Local News


Photo Albums

phpws Business Directory

Mark Twain Medical Center
Meadowmont Pharmacy
Bank of Stockton
Bear Valley Real Estate
Bear Valley Cross Country
Cave, Mine & Zip Lines
Fox Security
Bistro Espresso
Pinnacle Physical Therapy
Chatom Winery
Middleton's Furniture
Bear Valley Mountain Resort
Paul D. Bertini
Premier Properties
High Country Spa & Stove
Calaveras Mentoriing

Ebbetts Pass Scenic Byway
Sierra Logging Museum
Jenny's Kitchen

Copyright © The Pine Tree 2005-2021