The Pine Tree, News for Calaveras County and Beyond Weather
Amador Angels Camp Arnold Bear Valley Copperopolis Murphys San Andreas Valley Springs Moke Hill/West Point Tuolumne
Business Directory
Weather & Roads
Real Estate
Weekly & Grocery Ads
Life & Style
Law Enforcement
Wine News
Health & Fitness
Home & Garden
Food & Dining
Religion & Faith
Frogtown USA
Legal Notices
Free Classifieds
Letters to the Editor
About Us

Coming Soon...
Tuesday, Jun 2
10:00 AM Hospice of Amador & Calaveras Offering Weekly Grief Support
05:00 PM Angels Camp City Council Back in Action on June 2nd
06:00 PM Taco Tuesdays Are Back with Socially Distanced Live Entertainment Starting June 2nd!!
Wednesday, Jun 3
06:00 PM Overeaters Anonymous (OA)
Friday, Jun 5
All Day Get Your Fill of Fish & Chips Every Friday at Gooney's Bar & Grill
Saturday, Jun 6
All Day Bistro Espresso is Open late until 8:00pm! Join Us & Bring a Friend!
Sunday, Jun 7
All Day Our Sunday Edition with Local Features, Local Specials & More Every Sunday All Day Long!
Tuesday, Jun 9
10:00 AM Hospice of Amador & Calaveras Offering Weekly Grief Support
Wednesday, Jun 10
06:00 PM Overeaters Anonymous (OA)
Thursday, Jun 11
08:00 PM Thursdays is Karaoke Night at Gooney's Bar & Grill
Friday, Jun 12
All Day Get Your Fill of Fish & Chips Every Friday at Gooney's Bar & Grill
Sunday, Jun 14
All Day Our Sunday Edition with Local Features, Local Specials & More Every Sunday All Day Long!

Search Announcements

Log In


Remember Me

Posted by: thepinetree on 05/15/2020 05:33 PM Updated by: thepinetree on 05/15/2020 05:33 PM
Expires: 01/01/2025 12:00 AM

CCWD Wins on all Counts in Lawsuit Brought by Former Owner of La Contenta Golf Club

Valley Springs, CA...The Calaveras County Water District (CCWD) was notified on Thursday May 7, 2020, that it prevailed in a lawsuit filed in 2011 by Plaintiff La Contenta Investors, Ltd. The Plaintiff sold the La Contenta Golf Club in 2018 and is not associated with the current golf course owners who have a productive partnership with CCWD. This lawsuit involved a dispute between Ryan Voorhees, one of the former owners of La Contenta Golf Club, and CCWD regarding $1.8 million in sewer capacity credits. Voorhees claimed CCWD owed his company in exchange for using a specified amount of recycled water from CCWD’s treated wastewater plant to irrigate the golf course.

CCWD and Mr. Voorhees’ company had an agreement that his company would use a certain amount of recycled water. The agreement also provided sewer capacity credits if certain improvements were made, or the company increased its use of recycled water over a certain threshold. In order to receive those credits, however, the company was required to increase its use of recycled water over an agreed-upon minimum quantity. Having the golf course increase its use of recycled water would alleviate the need for CCWD to pay for other projects to increase effluent disposal capacity. CCWD’s position is that Voorhees and his company did not make improvements to accommodate additional capacity and did not meet the contractual requirements that would have obligated CCWD to award them additional credits. Voorhees claimed that CCWD’s infrastructure was unable to deliver the agreed-upon amount of recycled water and thus his company was entitled to recover the full amount of potential credits under the parties’ agreement, which CCWD disputed.

After nearly 10 years of litigation, the judge found that CCWD met all its contractual obligations and Voorhees’ company had not earned any additional sewer capacity credits. Thus, the Court found CCWD had no obligation to compensate Voorhees and his company. CCWD’s general counsel, Matt Weber, of Downey Brand LLP, skillfully handled the litigation and is now seeking to recover CCWD’s legal defense costs.

CCWD relies on its golf course partners in Valley Springs, Copperopolis, and Forest Meadows to dispose of its clean reclaimed water through irrigation. These partnerships are critical to the District’s wastewater operations and are mutually beneficial relationships that reduce costs for CCWD’s ratepayers and decrease golf courses’ reliance on surface water for irrigation. It was unfortunate that this matter resulted in litigation, but the outcome of this case has no bearing on the District’s ongoing relationships with its current golf course partners or with Mr. Voorhees, as his business enterprises continue to invest in local development.

For more information, contact Joel Metzger, External Affairs Manager, at or (209) 754-3123. Learn more at

Comments - Make a comment
The comments are owned by the poster. We are not responsible for its content. We value free speech but remember this is a public forum and we hope that people would use common sense and decency. If you see an offensive comment please email us at
No Subject
Posted on: 2020-05-15 18:13:05   By: Anonymous
This story does not smell like Mr. Rose. It stinks to high heaven.

[Reply ]

No Subject
Posted on: 2020-05-15 20:24:00   By: Anonymous
Another stars in his eyes, over extended developer of which there have been many in Calaveras. Voorhees will walk away and there is nothing to be gained. Once again, the only real winners are the lawyers. (Take note current protesters with your lawsuit against the county via Ochea.)

[Reply ]

    Posted on: 2020-05-15 20:28:13   By: Anonymous
    Who allowed Voorhes to renege on the fixing og Garner x Hwy 26? Politics at its best

    [Reply ]

No Subject
Posted on: 2020-05-16 06:19:53   By: Anonymous
How's dating going Bertha?

[Reply ]

No Subject
Posted on: 2020-05-17 02:03:05   By: Anonymous
The spraying of sewer on the golf course in the middle of a housing subdivision will come back to haunt the people and their health.

The sewer leaking into Lake Tulloch has all the homeowners around the lake trying to sell right now before the litigation starts, let alone their health.

This sewer mess is happening everywhere now.

Wastewater Treatment Plants Dumping Sewage On Farms, Open Space

Bioluminescent glow draws visitors, and police, to SoCal beaches

[Reply ]

    Posted on: 2020-05-17 07:21:54   By: Anonymous
    That lawsuit cost Voorhees thousands of dollars.

    [Reply ]

    Posted on: 2020-05-17 12:50:15   By: Anonymous
    CCWD does not spray sewer on golf courses. It is clean reclaimed water that is filtered and treated multiple times before it is used for irrigation. This is a common practice throughout the state and is heavily regulated.

    It's also not true that CCWD spills wastewater into Lake Tulloch. False rumors like that could hurt our community.

    Keep in mind there are a lot of good, hard working, local people at CCWD who care about our communities.

    [Reply ]

      Posted on: 2020-05-18 07:17:23   By: Anonymous
      And there's a lot of DEAD WOOD employees to.

      [Reply ]

What's Related
These might interest you as well

Local News

Photo Albums

phpws Business Directory

Web Pages

Mark Twain Medical Center
Meadowmont Pharmacy
Bank of Stockton
Bear Valley Real Estate
Bear Valley Cross Country
Cedar Creek Realty
Cave, Mine & Zip Lines
Fox Security
Bistro Espresso
Pinnacle Physical Therapy
Chatom Winery
Middleton's Furniture
Bear Valley Mountain Resort
Paul D. Bertini
Premier Properties
High Country Spa & Stove
Calaveras Mentoriing

Ebbetts Pass Scenic Byway
Sierra Logging Museum
Jenny's Kitchen

Copyright © The Pine Tree 2005-2020